Learning in the classroom is only half the picture. The real test comes when students meet a challenge that hasn’t been modelled for them or when they need to explain an idea under pressure.
We recently surveyed students on The Panel to understand how confident they feel across the core skills that underpin successful learning: problem-solving, communication, teamwork, critical thinking and motivation. The results reveal a group that’s largely confident and driven, but also clear about where they want to improve.
This is not a study of deficits. Most teenagers reported high comfort in teams, strong motivation to improve even when learning is difficult and high confidence in their ability to think critically. However, when asked where they’d most like to grow, two areas were highlighted: communicating ideas clearly and strengthening specific thinking skills under pressure.
Key Takeaways
- High baseline confidence appears across teamwork, critical thinking and motivation, with the majority of Panellists reporting at least moderate comfort in each area.
- Communication remains the clearest development priority, with speaking clearly and concisely chosen as the skill teens most want to improve.
- Strategic problem-solving presents the biggest challenge when difficulties arise; choosing a strategy is harder than understanding the problem or explaining the solution.
- Resilience and adaptability are strong, with most teens reporting they stay motivated when learning is difficult and adjust at least somewhat easily when plans change.
- Thinking skills are valued as specific capabilities not general traits; teens identify critical thinking, decision-making and problem-solving as the areas they most want to strengthen.
We Help Students Seize the Future
Our immersive programmes give young people with big dreams the opportunity to unlock their potential.
How Confident Do Teens Feel About Their Core Skills?
Across the data, three areas stand out for high confidence: 69.4% of Panellists reported high confidence in critical thinking, 65% in motivation and 62% in teamwork. These figures suggest that most teens feel broadly capable of engaging with complex information, sustaining effort when learning is difficult and working collaboratively with others.
The consistency across these three areas is worth noting. High critical-thinking confidence and strong motivation often go together; teens who feel capable of evaluating information also tend to report greater persistence when challenges arise. Meanwhile, high team comfort reflects positive peer dynamics and a willingness to participate in group settings, a foundation that supports both academic collaboration and informal social learning.
While overall confidence is high, the distribution reveals pockets where targeted support could make a difference. For example, 90% of respondents reported at least moderate confidence when learning new skills, yet 10% remain only slightly confident, indicating a small group who may benefit from structured skill-building environments. Similarly, combined lower-confidence responses for expressing ideas in discussions or presentations total 17%, suggesting that while most teens feel at least moderately confident communicating, a meaningful minority would value additional practice or feedback.
These patterns do not point to widespread deficits. Instead, they highlight that even in a confident cohort, opportunities exist to move individuals from moderate to high confidence through focused attention, whether that means rehearsing presentations, practicing unfamiliar problem-solving methods or receiving clearer guidance when starting something new.
Which Communication Skills Do Teens Most Want to Improve?
Communication emerges as the single clearest area where teens want to develop further. When asked which communication skill they would most like to improve, 20 Panellists chose speaking clearly and concisely, twice as many as the next highest option. Explaining complex ideas, writing ideas in a structured way and asking good questions were also frequently selected.
The emphasis on clarity and conciseness is telling. It suggests that many teens feel they have ideas to share but lack confidence in their ability to articulate those ideas efficiently, particularly in real-time discussions or presentations. This concern is practical rather than abstract; being able to explain a point quickly and clearly matters in seminars, group work, interviews and everyday conversations where hesitation or wordiness may undermine credibility.
Communication Skills Teens Most Want to Improve
20
10
9
8
1
Interestingly, 30 of 46 respondents (65%) reported being moderately or very confident in discussions or presentations, 15 were moderately confident and 15 very confident. Only 2 respondents reported feeling not at all confident.
This distribution suggests that most teens are not starting from zero. They participate, they contribute, but many still feel room for improvement. This is the kind of confidence gap that responds well to structured practice, whether through mock presentations, discussion-based learning or feedback on how to frame arguments more tightly.
What Happens When Problem-Solving Gets Difficult?
When solving difficult problems, it seems the biggest challenge for teens is not understanding what the problem is or explaining the solution once found, but rather choosing a strategy. 16 respondents identified this as the hardest part, higher than checking accuracy (11), understanding the problem (10), explaining the solution (8) or applying knowledge (3).
What Teens Find Hardest When Solving a Difficult Problem
16
11
10
8
3
This finding reflects a common experience. Many students can grasp concepts and follow worked examples but struggle when they must decide which approach to use without guidance. The gap is strategic rather than technical, a matter of knowing when to apply what rather than whether you understand the tools themselves.
When asked how comfortable they felt trying new or unfamiliar problem-solving methods, most Panellists reported feeling moderately comfortable (22). Only 5 respondents reported being extremely comfortable, suggesting that openness to new approaches is present but rarely at the level of confident experimentation.
This distribution is consistent with a generation willing to try but cautious about getting it wrong. Building greater comfort with unfamiliar methods often requires environments where trial and error is normalised, where students can test strategies without immediate grading pressure and where choosing the wrong path is treated as part of the learning process rather than a failure.
How Do Teens Respond to Frustration and Shifting Plans?
Resilience appears in how students respond when learning becomes frustrating or when plans change unexpectedly. The most frequent coping strategy when frustrated is to take a break then return (24 respondents), a pragmatic approach that allows space for emotional reset without abandoning the task entirely.
Motivation levels remain high even when learning becomes difficult. Only 2 respondents reported being not at all motivated, with the majority (65%) self-reporting as very motivated (15) or extremely motivated (11).
These figures suggest that most teens are not easily discouraged. They may pause, they may feel frustrated, but they remain willing to persist. This persistence is a valuable baseline, particularly when combined with strategic support. Students who are motivated but uncertain about how to proceed benefit most from guidance on method selection, not encouragement to try harder.
How Comfortable Do Teens Feel in Social and Team Settings?
Teamwork comfort is high. When asked how comfortable they feel working in a team, 29 of 47 respondents (62%) reported being very or extremely comfortable, while 14 were moderately comfortable and only 4 slightly comfortable. No respondents reported being not at all comfortable, indicating that aversion to group work is rare.
When asked about their usual strengths in teamwork situations, organising or leading was chosen by 27 Panellists, well ahead of all other options. Sharing ideas, solving problems, keeping the group focused and supporting others were less frequently cited. This distribution suggests that many teens see themselves in coordination or leadership roles rather than purely contributive or facilitative ones.
Team Strengths and Roles
27
11
4
3
3
Which Thinking Skills Do Teens Want to Strengthen Most?
When asked which thinking skill they most want to improve, critical thinking came out on top. Decision-making and problem-solving were tied as the second-highest priorities, indicating strong interest in practical, outcome-oriented skills. Attention to detail lagged behind, with creativity the least selected option.
The priority placed on critical thinking is notable given that confidence in this area is already high. 26 respondents (53%) reported feeling very confident in their ability to think critically about information they read or hear, and another 11 (22%) were moderately confident. Combined, “moderately”, “very” and “extremely confident” accounted for 92% of all responses, meaning low-confidence responses are rare.
This apparent contradiction, where teens are confident but still want to improve, may reflect an understanding that critical thinking is not a single skill but a set of capabilities that can always be refined. Students who feel capable of evaluating arguments or identifying bias may still recognise that they lack specific strategies for analysing complex data, constructing counterarguments or applying logic under time pressure.
What Does This Mean?
Our Panel data reveals a group with strong baseline confidence, high motivation and solid collaboration readiness. Most teens feel capable of working in teams, thinking critically and staying focused when challenged. However, the clearest gaps appear not in general confidence but in specific execution skills: speaking clearly under pressure, choosing the right problem-solving strategy and expressing ideas concisely in real-time discussions.
These findings suggest that the most meaningful impact comes from targeted skill-building rather than broad encouragement. Teens do not need to be told to work harder or believe in themselves more; they need structured opportunities to practice articulating complex ideas quickly, selecting strategies without guidance and navigating unfamiliar methods with less caution.
The data points to a generation that is ready to improve but waiting for the right kind of support to do so.
For data-led curricula, university-style teaching and real-world challenges that develop these sought-after skills, explore our Oxford Summer School programmes.
Methodology. Oxford Scholastica Academy collected original data from students aged 13–18 on The Panel. All findings reported in this article are based exclusively on responses provided by participants in this survey.
By Oxford Scholastica Academy
Since 2013, Oxford Scholastica’s award-winning programmes have empowered thousands of students to seize the future. We have welcomed bright students from around the globe for more than a decade, giving them the edge to help them succeed, find their purpose and make a difference in the world.
